Getting learners to think about their writing BEFORE they put pen to paper is a thankless task. Most seem to prefer the “stream of consciousness” approach, where the words flow ceaselessly out of the brain, down the arm and out, via the pen, onto the page. I have, in the past, spent months hammering home the point and process of planning a piece of writing – even to the point of insisting my classes include a plan with every piece of writing they submit. No plan – no grade.
I gave up on that approach after a student came up to me at the end of one lesson and handed me his essay. “Teacher, I’m really sorry but I didn’t have much time for my homework. I wrote the essay for you, but is it OK if I write the plan later?”
Now, on reflection, what I think is interesting about that comment is that the learner clearly didn’t associate planning with the creation of a successful text. The final product to be assessed was, in his view, more important than the process of getting there.
What I’m beginning to wonder is whether the same view might be more prevalent amongst teachers than it is with learners? When it comes to lesson planning, do we practice what we preach?
Confession time. You might find this hard to believe, but not every lesson plan I write includes aims, assumptions, anticipated problems and solutions, timetable fit, stages, stage aims, timings, procedures, interaction patterns and material references. In fact I think the last time I did any of that was on 6th June 2007, which – not entirely uncoincidentally – was the last time I was observed.
These days, my planning process goes a bit more like this:
- What should the learners be better at doing by the end of the lesson?
- How will I know if they are better at doing it?
- What do they need to know to get better at it?
- How can I make the whole process interesting for them?
And then after I’ve spent 45 minutes swearing at the course book for not helping with any aspect of this process, I scribble about six stages down on the back of a discarded handout, do some photocopying and we’re done. Sound familiar?
So here’s my question – am I alone? How does everybody else do their planning? Let me know!